SPECIAL TEAMS: C-
2009: Washington's offense got almost no help from the special teams in 2009, as the team finished dead last in the NFL in return average. KR Rock Cartwright had his worst season on special teams, averaging only 22.3 yards per return -- more than 3 yards less than the year before and the first time since taking over the job in 2005 that his average fell below 24 yards per return. Cartwright lost his job for a few weeks to Devin Thomas, but his 22 yards per return average was even worse. PR Antwaan Randle El was a disaster, with more fair catches [19] than returns [17] and a dismal 6.0 yards per return average. Even that was misleadingly bloated, though, because if you take out just one return of 43 yards, Randle El averaged 3.8 yards per return. Even worse, Randle El fumbled 3 times, a very high percentage considering his number of returns. Finally, when criticism of his performance mounted, Randle El took to blaming his blockers instead of shouldering the responsibility himself. The Redskins feinted at replacing Randle El with some combination of Santana Moss and DeAngelo Smith, but injuries and coaching incompetence led to nothing really happening.
Punter Hunter Smith ran and threw for touchdowns, but his 41.2 yards per punt average represented perhaps the worst season of his career. He also struggled with injuries during much of the season and wasn't really the solution the team hoped he would be. PK Shaun Suisham started out very well, but missed a key 39-yard field goal in Dallas that cost the team a win and then missed a 23-yarder against the Saints that cost the team another win. Fed up, the Redskins fired Suisham and replaced him with Graham Gano, a youngster with a big leg. Gano played in four games and hit all 4 field goal attempts, including a long of 46 yards, but had one extra point blocked. His kickoffs were long and 3 touchbacks in 16 total kicks.
The only area where the Redskins excelled on special teams was the coverage units, which were among the best in the NFL. Standouts were Rock Cartwright and Lorenzo Alexander, who delivered several eye-popping hits while covering kicks.
2010: The Redskins were not much helped by their special teams in 2009, but special teams coach Danny Smith was retained anyway but new head coach Mike Shanahan, so expect few changes schematically in the special teams for 2010. Cartwright is unhappy with his lot on the team and his salary balloons to $1.5 million in 2010 so he may not be around much longer. P Hunter Smith is a free agent and the Redskins may well try to replace him with a younger and cheaper model. Gano looks promising, but expect competition for his position in 2010 because he only played 4 games and Shanahan doesn't know the first thing about him. The team will definitely need a new punt returner, as Randle El has long since been past his sell by date.